Skip to main content

Inspirational Novel vs. Christian novels

I'm trying to do research on the difference between an inspirational and a Christian novel?

I'm coming up empty handed in defining the difference. I can define them apart but not one versus the other.

I have some scripture references in the novel, HUNGRY FOR CHOCOLATE, and I'm trying to determine if it would fit into the category of the inspirational novel but thinking it might be too lighthearted for the Christian market. In a quandary here!

I'm excited to go shopping soon and  look at the categories at book stores to see what I can find. I thought I'd buy a few books to read to see if I can find the differences.

I've read inspirational romances and I know that category well. I like to read them but don't want to write one.

My book is women's mainstream and I'm willing to do a total rewrite - after I decide which way to go.

Any comments, suggestions, or advice will be much appreciated.

Any recommendations for reading in those categories.

I need to get busy.

Thanks, Barb

Comments

  1. This is a good question. I have no idea of the answer, but am truly interested in finding out.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Does one have to exclude the other?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think the Christian genre relies heavily on God, using scripture, the Bible, praying, allowing all things that happen in the book to come from God.

    And Inspirational is, more of an undefined divine presence. Encompassing all faiths so not to insult anyone.

    I think angels are used a lot in Inspirationals.

    And you might want to look in the archives over at Rachel Gardners blog. She might have the definitions listed somewhere. Or send her an email, I know she answers on her blog.

    Hope that helps somewhat.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I certainly can't give you an answer, but I'm looking forward to what you come up with and reading your finished product!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sorry, I'm no help either, Barbara. But it sounds like Anne may have helped you with her answer.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Inspirational writing appeals to a wider audience, with themes that are applicable to all people, no matter what their belief system.

    Christian works are for a specific group within the wider range.

    For an example, look at the song, Amazing Grace. At first glance, this seems specifically Christian, especially the line, "we've no less days to sing God's praise. But the theme; losing your way and finding it once more, is not specific to Christianity. When I sing the song, I don't mean I turned toward Jesus. I mean I've found MY way, after wandering in the fog of other people's religions for a long time, feeling lost and somehow incomplete. This song is quite universal. Singing "God's praise", to those of us who are not Christian, means singing our praise song. Praise lives in every open heart and is not specific to one belief system.

    For the song to be truly inspirational rather than inspirational Christian, slightly different wording would have been used.

    ReplyDelete
  7. All your answers helped. I get it now. And it seems so much simpler than I'd first thought. I think I was making it difficult.
    While I am a Christian - I write in many different genres.
    So thanks all for commenting. Finally it's in my head.
    I'd never thought of amazing grace being anything other than Christian.
    Interesting take on it. Blessings all.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have a version of Amazing Grace by Krishna Dass. There is even a version in Cherokee. Sometimes folks change a word or two here and there. It is a much loved song by people of various paths.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Everything Christian is based on Christ. Last week I was in a fog. Or as my mother would say, I was running around like a chicken with its head cut off!!!
    Blessings everyone for your help.
    No longer in a muddle over this one.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Glad you found your answer! I was going to say that reading the different genres might help to decide which category to place your work in :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Yes, I agree with Anne that (to me) Christian is specific and Inspirational is generic where wisdom, angels and other things are included.

    Thanks for making me think on this.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ah, Spring and all her glory.

I'm enjoying the spring weather that has finally arrived in Ohio bringing blooming pear trees, red buds and tulip trees. How about you? Do you love spring as much as I do? I spent a day on the patio, putting out the table, chairs, umbrella. I painted a white wicker plant table and have decided it's too good for the patio. I plan to use it in the bathroom instead. Just when I thought winter would last forever, spring arrived with temperatures in the 70's. I noted buds covering my rose bush and a robin building a nest in the crevice of my chimney. I wanted to let them stay but they managed to leave so much debris at my front door that I had no choice but to shoo them away. Hopefully they've moved on to one of the many trees and bushes in my community, a more cozy place for raising babies. When I was a kid growing up in Putnam County, WV, I was outside at the first glimpse of the sun coming through my bedroom window. I ran through our yard, down through the orcha

The Dreaded School Pictures

This year when my children brought home their school pictures, I cringed.  These kids can leave home looking cherubic, but the minute they pose for that school photographer they are transposed into unrecognizable beings.  My middle daughter brought home pictures bearing her name and room number that couldn't have been my offspring. Nor a distant relative. I had worked for hours on this child. Her hair was parted in the middle and drawn into a cute little ponytail over each ear. Even though she is at an awkward age, she looked adorable when she went out that door. Her missing front teeth only added to her charm.  The kid in the picture has her mouth open wide displaying ugly dark gaps. Her one visible ponytail is lopsided, her part is uneven, and her bangs look like they were cut with pinking shears. I know this isn't my child because I always give my children a good haircut before they have their pictures taken. The only thing vaguely familiar is the sweater t

MY HIGH SCHOOL EXPERIENCE...

Wednesday, March 16, 2011 High School - Poca High School, Putnam County, WV What year was it? Fall 1960 - Spring 1963 What were your favorite bands, or singers? Sam Cook, Chubby Checker, Conway Twitty (It's only make believe), Johnny Rodriquez. Meatloaf. ELvis. What was your favorite outfit? Straight skirts, blouses, cardigans or jackets, little heels. Other Outfits? Jeans and a white Dr. Ben Casey shirt. What was up with your hair? Everything. I put peroxide on it. Lemon juice, thinking it needed to be lighter. I cut it, styled it, put it in a pony tail or a french twist. Hair was the most important thing in my life in high school. And hair spray, the stiffer the better. Who were your best friends? Patti Jones, Karen Mattox, and Susie Bailey all thru elem school. Then added on Donna Dailey, Sharon "Mouse" Hackett and Janice Wick and many others. Also Bonnie Kerwood who was older than me and lived near me so we hung out listening to records after schoo