Skip to main content

Inspirational Novel vs. Christian novels

I'm trying to do research on the difference between an inspirational and a Christian novel?

I'm coming up empty handed in defining the difference. I can define them apart but not one versus the other.

I have some scripture references in the novel, HUNGRY FOR CHOCOLATE, and I'm trying to determine if it would fit into the category of the inspirational novel but thinking it might be too lighthearted for the Christian market. In a quandary here!

I'm excited to go shopping soon and  look at the categories at book stores to see what I can find. I thought I'd buy a few books to read to see if I can find the differences.

I've read inspirational romances and I know that category well. I like to read them but don't want to write one.

My book is women's mainstream and I'm willing to do a total rewrite - after I decide which way to go.

Any comments, suggestions, or advice will be much appreciated.

Any recommendations for reading in those categories.

I need to get busy.

Thanks, Barb
Labels:

Comments

  1. Sally WesselyJune 25, 2011 at 12:33 AM

    This is a good question. I have no idea of the answer, but am truly interested in finding out.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The BroadJune 25, 2011 at 3:55 AM

    Does one have to exclude the other?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anne GallagherJune 25, 2011 at 6:58 AM

    I think the Christian genre relies heavily on God, using scripture, the Bible, praying, allowing all things that happen in the book to come from God.

    And Inspirational is, more of an undefined divine presence. Encompassing all faiths so not to insult anyone.

    I think angels are used a lot in Inspirationals.

    And you might want to look in the archives over at Rachel Gardners blog. She might have the definitions listed somewhere. Or send her an email, I know she answers on her blog.

    Hope that helps somewhat.

    ReplyDelete
  4. yayaJune 25, 2011 at 11:09 PM

    I certainly can't give you an answer, but I'm looking forward to what you come up with and reading your finished product!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Janet,June 25, 2011 at 11:50 PM

    Sorry, I'm no help either, Barbara. But it sounds like Anne may have helped you with her answer.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Granny KateJune 26, 2011 at 5:43 PM

    Inspirational writing appeals to a wider audience, with themes that are applicable to all people, no matter what their belief system.

    Christian works are for a specific group within the wider range.

    For an example, look at the song, Amazing Grace. At first glance, this seems specifically Christian, especially the line, "we've no less days to sing God's praise. But the theme; losing your way and finding it once more, is not specific to Christianity. When I sing the song, I don't mean I turned toward Jesus. I mean I've found MY way, after wandering in the fog of other people's religions for a long time, feeling lost and somehow incomplete. This song is quite universal. Singing "God's praise", to those of us who are not Christian, means singing our praise song. Praise lives in every open heart and is not specific to one belief system.

    For the song to be truly inspirational rather than inspirational Christian, slightly different wording would have been used.

    ReplyDelete
  7. B. WHITTINGTONJune 26, 2011 at 7:54 PM

    All your answers helped. I get it now. And it seems so much simpler than I'd first thought. I think I was making it difficult.
    While I am a Christian - I write in many different genres.
    So thanks all for commenting. Finally it's in my head.
    I'd never thought of amazing grace being anything other than Christian.
    Interesting take on it. Blessings all.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Granny KateJune 27, 2011 at 8:22 PM

    I have a version of Amazing Grace by Krishna Dass. There is even a version in Cherokee. Sometimes folks change a word or two here and there. It is a much loved song by people of various paths.

    ReplyDelete
  9. B. WHITTINGTONJune 28, 2011 at 11:01 PM

    Everything Christian is based on Christ. Last week I was in a fog. Or as my mother would say, I was running around like a chicken with its head cut off!!!
    Blessings everyone for your help.
    No longer in a muddle over this one.

    ReplyDelete
  10. JoanneJune 29, 2011 at 1:22 PM

    Glad you found your answer! I was going to say that reading the different genres might help to decide which category to place your work in :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. T. Powell ColtrinJune 30, 2011 at 7:36 AM

    Yes, I agree with Anne that (to me) Christian is specific and Inspirational is generic where wisdom, angels and other things are included.

    Thanks for making me think on this.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Shingles: not the roofing kind...

Just when I thought things could not get any worse at our house my husband R came down with shingles. On the day I had to be at the hospital in Columbus with one adult daughter in the morning and then go to Cincinnati to pick up her husband after his stomach surgery the day before, R gets up with a rash that had turned to blisters. We made a quick dash 40 miles away to our family Dr. for a check up and yes my diagnosis was correct. Shingles! So armed with two medications we headed to the medical center to see our daughter, then to Cincinnati to pick up her husband and then home to collapse and hope that that's the end of our downward spiral. I'm worn to a frazzle and so is R. No time for writing or fretting about writing. I do feel good knowing that I have some contest entries out (short stories and one novel) and will be working on my novel at least two days this coming week. I have my writers meeting on Monday at Great Expectations Cafe and Book Store and look for...
21 comments
Read more

A Revolutionary New Diet...

Recently I went on a diet. Like most diets this one was scheduled around a major life event. My daughter's wedding. There would be no shopping for a mother-of-the-bride dress until the pounds came off. Typically I go on a diet on Monday and by Wednesday I've folded beneath the weight of a German chocolate cake. I've been hijacked by as little as a stale pink sugar wafer discovered in the dark recesses of the bread drawer. But this time things were going to be different. I could tell as I went to get the mail and discovered the first crocus of the season. Life was looking up. Even though an icy rain began to fall, my spirits weren't dampened. Not even when huge drops pelted me on the head and I had to dash inside. My latest plan would revolutionize dieting. If it worked for me it would work for the world. I smelled a book deal. I could see myself all made-over and liposuctioned sitting between Oprah and Dr. Oz. It was full speed ahead. Gone were those complex menus...
23 comments
Read more

Mother's Leather Britches...

My mother gardened all her life. It was one of her great loves, next to family, God, and country. Because she grew up during the Depression, she learned to use every last item from her garden for canning, preserving, drying or pickling. Every year at the end of the green bean season she made leather britches, dried beans that would keep for the winter. These were the last beans hanging on the vines. The beans inside had grown to full size with outsides a bit withered. They were beyond the stage to can or preserve, or even to pickle. Although her fried pickled green beans and corn bread were the best in the world. (Well, next to her biscuits and fried apples.) Mother started the drying process with clean beans. She would spread a clean white sheet on a table in the wash room and spread the beans out on that, giving them space to dry. Sometime she would carry the sheet outside and put them on a table in the sun to further the process. The next step involved needle and thread ...
18 comments
Read more